Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Past Transactions

We have contracted and sold over $3 billion of luxury homes in Sarasota and Longboat Key.

TESTIMONIALS

"Roger and his team are consummate professionals who communicate often and clearly. Having used other agents before and using Roger on our sale, the experience with his team is head and shoulders above anything that I’ve experienced in past. If you..."

- Tim V.

"Roger has a pedigree of multi-million dollar annual sales and delivered on his experience. He knew all about other agents in the area, other sales, other potential sales and could discuss his recommendations for listing and showing the property wi..."

- Mr. And Mrs. McLennan

"Roger and his team put everything into making sure our home sold. We had several items that came up that they assisted with completing to be sure it all went smoothly and we closed when we wanted to. Very happy and would recommend Roger and his te..."

- Gray V.

Recently Sold Properties in Sarasota

Explore our successful transactions and gain valuable market insights from Sarasota's premier luxury real estate team

$128M+
Total Volume Sold
97%
List-to-Sale Ratio
42
Days Avg. Time to Sell
View Sold Properties

Sarasota Luxury Market Performance

Luxury Home Sales Trends

Sarasota's luxury market ($1M+) has seen a 12% increase in closed sales year-over-year, with waterfront properties commanding premium prices. The average sale price for luxury single-family homes reached $2.3M in Q2 2023.

Neighborhood Highlights

Bird Key properties sold for an average of 98% of asking price, while Siesta Key beachfront condos saw record prices at $1,250/sqft. Lakewood Ranch continues to attract buyers with its master-planned amenities.

Seller Advantages

Properly priced luxury homes in Sarasota are selling in just 28 days on average. Our professional staging and marketing strategies have helped clients achieve 6-12% above market value.

Sarasota Luxury Market Comparison (Last 12 Months)

Neighborhood Avg. Sale Price Price/SqFt Days on Market List-to-Sale
Bird Key $2.45M $875 37 97.2%
Siesta Key $1.85M $1,025 45 96.8%
Lido Key $2.15M $950 42 97.5%
Lakewood Ranch $1.35M $325 28 98.1%
Longboat Key $2.75M $1,150 51 96.3%

Recently Sold Properties

SOLD
Sold waterfront estate in Bird Key
Sold for $2,650,000

525 Seagate Dr, Bird Key

5 Beds 4.5 Baths 4,200 sqft
List Price: $2,595,000
Sale Price: $2,650,000
Days on Market: 14

Spectacular deepwater estate with 125' of bay frontage, private dock, and resort-style pool. Sold for 102% of asking price in just two weeks.

View Details
SOLD
Sold beachfront condo in Siesta Key
Sold for $1,125,000

245 Beach Rd #501, Siesta Key

2 Beds 2 Baths 1,650 sqft
List Price: $1,150,000
Sale Price: $1,125,000
Days on Market: 22

Direct beachfront condo with panoramic Gulf views, completely renovated with high-end finishes. Sold at 98% of list price.

View Details
SOLD
Sold estate in Lakewood Ranch
Sold for $1,875,000

7320 Champions Blvd, Lakewood Ranch

4 Beds 3.5 Baths 3,850 sqft
List Price: $1,825,000
Sale Price: $1,875,000
Days on Market: 9

Elegant golf course estate in The Concession with smart home technology, custom finishes, and outdoor living space. Sold for 103% of asking price.

View Details

Seller Success Stories

Robert and Susan Thompson

Robert & Susan Thompson

Sold for $2.65M in Bird Key

" We were amazed when our Bird Key home sold in just two weeks for above asking price. The Pettingell team's marketing strategy brought multiple offers and created a competitive bidding situation.

Original Purchase Price: $1,850,000 (2018)
Sale Price: $2,650,000
Appreciation: 43.2%
Maria Gonzalez

Maria Gonzalez

Sold for $1.125M in Siesta Key

" As an out-of-state owner, I needed a team I could trust. Pettingell handled everything professionally and got me top dollar for my condo. The professional photography and virtual tour made all the difference.

Original Purchase Price: $875,000 (2019)
Sale Price: $1,125,000
Appreciation: 28.6%
James Wilson

James Wilson

Sold for $1.875M in Lakewood Ranch

" The market analysis and pricing strategy were spot on. We had multiple offers within a week and closed above asking. The entire process was seamless from start to finish.

Original Purchase Price: $1,450,000 (2020)
Sale Price: $1,875,000
Appreciation: 29.3%

What's Your Home Worth?

Get a complimentary market analysis and find out how much your Sarasota property could sell for in today's market.

Follow Us

WORK WITH US

At Pettingell Professionals, success isn’t just about numbers—it’s about the impact we make and the milestones we achieve for our clients. With nearly $3 billion in career sales and a record-breaking $221+ million in closed sales in 2024, our results speak for themselves. These accomplishments reflect the trust our clients place in us and our unwavering commitment to delivering exceptional service and outstanding results. Whether breaking records or setting new standards, our focus remains on helping you achieve your goals with precision, expertise, and care—because at Pettingell Professionals, your success is our success.

Contact