Lighthouse Point

One of Longboat Key's Most Exclusive Waterfront Enclaves

Some communities are defined by their amenities. Others are defined by their location. Lighthouse Point is defined by both, but above all, by its rarity. Developed as a private gated neighborhood in the late 1980s, Lighthouse Point was thoughtfully planned as an intimate collection of just sixteen custom waterfront homes.

Its location is unlike any other on the island. Situated on a peninsula overlooking New Pass and the Intracoastal Waterway, Lighthouse Point offers protected deep-water boating with quick access to Sarasota Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. Many residences enjoy private docks, while the community also maintains shared dock facilities with a recently installed 16,000-pound boat lift for designated owners.

Perhaps the strongest testament to Lighthouse Point's appeal is how rarely homes become available.

Custom waterfront homes

Late 1980s

Developed

No Fixed Bridges

Deep-water boating

~20

MLS sales in ~20 years

New Pass & ICW

Waterfront frontage

Why Buyers Love Lighthouse Point

Sixteen homes. True exclusivity.

Lighthouse Point appeals to buyers looking for something few communities can offer: true exclusivity.

With only sixteen homes, a gated entrance, and exceptionally limited turnover, ownership opportunities are among the rarest on Longboat Key. The neighborhood's location allows residents to enjoy deep-water boating, beautiful waterfront views, and a quiet residential setting while remaining just minutes from golf, tennis, fine dining, shopping, and Sarasota's vibrant downtown.

Boaters are especially drawn to Lighthouse Point for its protected waters and convenient access to Sarasota Bay, New Pass, and the Gulf of Mexico. For many homeowners, however, the greatest luxury is simply the privacy — the community feels secluded without feeling isolated.

Longboat Key ClubThe Links Golf CourseSt. Armands CircleDowntown Sarasota

The Story Behind Lighthouse Point

An intimate peninsula, by design.

Lighthouse Point was developed during a period when southern Longboat Key was evolving into one of Florida's premier luxury waterfront destinations.

Late 1980s

Sixteen Custom Estates

Rather than creating a large subdivision, the developers chose a different approach, designing an intimate neighborhood of just sixteen custom homes on a naturally protected peninsula. Each residence was individually designed, creating an appealing mix of architectural styles while allowing homeowners to take full advantage of the community's exceptional waterfront setting.

Today

One of the Island's Most Tightly Held Addresses

Over the years, Lighthouse Point has remained remarkably exclusive. Its combination of deep-water boating, privacy, and proximity to both Longboat Key and Sarasota amenities has made it one of the island's most tightly held residential communities, with very few homes changing ownership.

Today, Lighthouse Point continues to represent one of Longboat Key's most coveted waterfront addresses.

Residences & Amenities

No two residences are exactly alike.

As a community of just sixteen custom homes, each estate was individually designed, resulting in a collection of distinctive waterfront homes that reflect a variety of architectural styles and personal tastes. Most homes feature private swimming pools, generous outdoor entertaining areas, and private docks capable of accommodating a variety of vessels, with deep-water access and no fixed bridges to Sarasota Bay, New Pass, and the Gulf of Mexico.

Shared Feature

Private Gated Entrance

Shared Feature

Community Dock & Boat Lift

Shared Feature

Private Tennis Court

Shared Feature

Landscaped Common Areas

Private gated entrance

Community dock

Recently installed 16,000-pound boat lift

Private neighborhood tennis court

Beautifully landscaped common areas

Deep-water boating with no fixed bridges

Private docks at most homes

Private swimming pools at most homes

Lifestyle Policies

What to know before you buy.

Pets	See the Association's governing documents for current pet policies.
Leasing	See the Association's governing documents for current leasing restrictions.
Parking	Private garages and driveways are provided at each residence.
Architectural Changes	Exterior modifications are subject to approval by the Homeowners Association.
Boating	Many homes include private docks. Community dock facilities and the shared 16,000-pound boat lift are available in accordance with Association rules.
Security	Private gated entrance.

Association rules may change over time. Buyers should verify current policies before purchasing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything buyers ask us first.

How many homes are in Lighthouse Point?

Lighthouse Point consists of just 16 custom waterfront residences, making it one of the most exclusive residential communities on Longboat Key.

When was Lighthouse Point developed?

The community was developed in the late 1980s as a private gated waterfront neighborhood.

What makes Lighthouse Point unique?

Its combination of exceptional location, deep-water boating, gated privacy, and extremely limited inventory makes Lighthouse Point one of Longboat Key's most sought-after neighborhoods. Only about 20 homes have changed hands through the MLS over approximately the past two decades.

Are all homes waterfront?

Yes. Every residence enjoys a waterfront setting, with most offering private docks and direct boating access to Sarasota Bay, New Pass, and the Gulf of Mexico.

What amenities are available?

Residents enjoy a gated entrance, community dock, recently installed 16,000-pound boat lift, private neighborhood tennis court, and convenient access to nearby Gulf beaches, the Resort at the Longboat Key Club, golf, tennis, fitness facilities, and marina services.

Is Lighthouse Point good for boaters?

Absolutely. Deep-water canals and direct access to New Pass allow residents to reach Sarasota Bay and the Gulf of Mexico without fixed bridges, making it one of Longboat Key's premier boating communities.

Does the community have an official website?

At the time of publication, Lighthouse Point does not maintain a public community website.

Buying in Lighthouse Point

Find your residence.

Few communities on Longboat Key offer the combination of exclusivity and location found at Lighthouse Point. With only sixteen residences and very limited turnover, buyers often wait years for the opportunity to purchase within the neighborhood. Understanding waterfront orientation, dock configuration, boating depth, renovation history, and individual property characteristics is essential when evaluating the few homes that become available. For more than four decades, Pettingell Professionals has represented buyers throughout Longboat Key's luxury waterfront market. We help our clients understand not only the homes themselves, but also the unique lifestyle and long-term value that make communities like Lighthouse Point so highly sought after.

Selling in Lighthouse Point

Tell your home's story.

Marketing a home in Lighthouse Point requires more than simply showcasing a beautiful waterfront property. Buyers are purchasing one of Longboat Key's rarest residential opportunities. The neighborhood's gated privacy, deep-water boating, exceptional location, and remarkably limited inventory all contribute to its enduring appeal. That's why we've created one of Sarasota's most comprehensive luxury community guides. Our goal is simple. When someone searches for Lighthouse Point Longboat Key, we want them to find the most accurate, informative, and complete resource available. More importantly, we want your home to be part of that discovery. Combined with exceptional photography, cinematic video, strategic digital marketing, and more than four decades of experience representing Sarasota and Longboat Key's finest waterfront properties, we position your home to reach qualified buyers seeking one of the Gulf Coast's most exclusive boating communities.

The Pettingell Community Guides

Exceptional real estate decisions begin with exceptional information.

The Pettingell Community Guides were created to provide buyers and sellers with accurate, objective, and thoughtfully researched information about Sarasota and Longboat Key's most exceptional condominium communities, residential neighborhoods, and waterfront enclaves. Every guide is independently researched, regularly updated, and written to help you understand not only the facts about a community, but also the history, lifestyle, architecture, and details that make it unique.

Rather than relying on marketing language or generic descriptions, our goal is to create the most complete and trustworthy resource available for each community we cover. Whether you're buying, selling, or simply exploring Sarasota's luxury real estate market, we hope these guides help you make more informed decisions and discover the communities that best fit your lifestyle.

Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Lighthouse Point