A Private Village Within Bay Isles
Corey's Landing offers one of the most charming residential settings on Longboat Key. Unlike many luxury neighborhoods built around a single home style, Corey's Landing was thoughtfully planned as a collection of distinctive residences woven around Sarasota Bay, lakes, golf course views, mature landscaping, and quiet winding streets.
The result is a neighborhood that feels established, peaceful, and remarkably private. Located behind the gates of Bay Isles, residents enjoy the privacy of a boutique community while benefiting from Bay Isles Beach Club access, community amenities, and convenient proximity to the Longboat Key Club, St. Armands Circle, and downtown Sarasota.
No two streets feel exactly alike, giving the neighborhood a character that's difficult to find in newer developments.
Corey's Landing appeals to buyers who want the privacy of a neighborhood with the convenience of a managed community. Some homes overlook Sarasota Bay, others enjoy golf course, lake, or garden views, while the variety of residences allows buyers to choose between maintenance-free paired villas and expansive custom homes.
No two streets feel exactly alike, giving the neighborhood a character that's difficult to find in newer developments.
Another reason buyers are drawn to Corey's Landing is the opportunity to enjoy an established neighborhood without sacrificing modern living. While many residences have been meticulously maintained, others have undergone extensive renovations or complete transformations, offering contemporary architecture, designer finishes, open floor plans, and resort-style outdoor living. It's a rare opportunity to enjoy the beauty of mature landscaping and an established Bay Isles address while still experiencing the feeling of moving into a new home.
Developed beginning in 1989, Corey's Landing reflected a thoughtful approach to luxury residential planning on Longboat Key.
Rather than repeating the same home throughout the neighborhood, the developers created a collection of residences arranged around Sarasota Bay, lakes, the Harbourside Golf Course, and beautifully landscaped common areas.
The gently curving streets and varied homesites give the neighborhood a village-like character that remains one of its defining qualities today. The original plat clearly illustrates this intentional design, with homes carefully positioned to take advantage of water, golf course, and garden views while preserving green space and privacy.
The original marketing materials introduced a collection of floor plans with names such as Belleaire, Somerset, Seabrook, Melrose, Amelia, Astor, Cumberland, St. George, St. Simon, and Seville, offering buyers a variety of layouts and architectural styles. Several premier waterfront homesites were reserved for substantially larger custom residences overlooking Sarasota Bay.
Today, that diversity remains one of Corey's Landing's greatest strengths, from beautifully maintained original homes to extensively renovated residences and impressive custom waterfront estates.
A rare opportunity to enjoy mature landscaping and an established Bay Isles address while still experiencing the feeling of moving into a new home.
Depending on the homesite, residences range from approximately 2,100 square feet to custom waterfront homes exceeding 6,000 square feet. Buyers will find everything from thoughtfully designed paired villas to expansive bayfront estates, each offering its own interpretation of luxury living, with many homes extensively renovated over the years to blend contemporary architecture and designer finishes with mature, established grounds.
Pets | Up to two household pets permitted. Pets must be leashed outside the owner's lot, and owners are responsible for cleanup. |
|---|---|
Parking | Owners and lessees are expected to park vehicles in their garages. Guests should use driveways or designated guest parking. |
Motorcycles | Permitted for ingress and egress only and must be stored inside garages when not in use. |
Noise | Quiet enjoyment expected, particularly between 11:00 PM and 8:00 AM. |
Architectural Changes | Exterior modifications require prior Architectural Review approval. |
Beach Club | Ownership includes membership to the private Bay Isles Beach Club. |
Association rules may change over time. Buyers should verify current policies before purchasing.
Corey's Landing consists of approximately 70 residences, including paired villas and single-family homes.
The community includes paired villas, golf course residences, lakefront homes, custom waterfront estates, and garden-view homes.
Development began in 1989 as one of the premier residential neighborhoods within Bay Isles.
Residences range from approximately 2,100 square feet to custom waterfront homes exceeding 6,000 square feet.
Original floor plans include Belleaire, Somerset, Seabrook, Melrose, Amelia, Astor, Cumberland, St. George, St. Simon, and Seville.
Yes. Numerous residences have undergone extensive renovations or complete transformations, allowing buyers to enjoy modern interiors while living in one of Longboat Key's most established neighborhoods.
Yes. Corey's Landing is located within the gated Bay Isles community.
Yes. Ownership includes membership to the private Bay Isles Beach Club on the Gulf of Mexico.
Yes. Owners may keep up to two household pets, subject to the Association's Rules and Regulations.
Its village-like setting, mature landscaping, mix of home styles, Bay Isles Beach Club membership, and combination of waterfront, golf course, lake, and garden homes create one of the most distinctive residential communities on Longboat Key.
Yes. Corey's Landing is one of the residential neighborhoods within Bay Isles. Visit the official Bay Isles community website.
Every neighborhood has its own personality. In Corey's Landing, homesite orientation, waterfront exposure, golf course location, floor plan, renovation level, outdoor living space, and proximity to community amenities can dramatically influence which home is the right fit. For more than four decades, Pettingell Professionals has helped buyers navigate Sarasota and Longboat Key's luxury residential market. We've had the privilege of watching communities like Corey's Landing evolve over time, giving us a unique perspective on what makes each neighborhood special and how one property compares with another. If Corey's Landing is on your shortlist, we'll help you understand not only which home best fits your lifestyle, but also how it compares with other exceptional communities throughout Bay Isles and Longboat Key.
Today's luxury buyers begin their search long before they schedule a showing. They compare neighborhoods, study floor plans, review renovations, explore community amenities, and look for trustworthy information before deciding which homes deserve a closer look. That's why we've created one of Sarasota's most comprehensive luxury condominium and residential community guides. Our goal is simple. When someone searches for Corey's Landing Longboat Key, we want them to find the most accurate, informative, and complete resource available. More importantly, we want your home to be part of that discovery. For sellers, this matters. A beautifully renovated Corey's Landing residence should never be presented as simply another home within Bay Isles. It deserves to be positioned within the story of the neighborhood, the quality of its renovation, the lifestyle it offers, and the long-term appeal of living in one of Longboat Key's most established private communities. Combined with exceptional photography, cinematic video, strategic digital marketing, and more than four decades of experience representing Sarasota's finest properties, we position your home where today's luxury buyers begin their search. We don't simply market luxury homes. We tell the story behind them, connect the right buyers with the right properties, and represent every client with the level of service that exceptional real estate deserves.
The Pettingell Community Guides were created to provide buyers and sellers with accurate, objective, and thoughtfully researched information about Sarasota and Longboat Key's most exceptional condominium communities, residential neighborhoods, and waterfront enclaves. Every guide is independently researched, regularly updated, and written to help you understand not only the facts about a community, but also the history, lifestyle, architecture, and details that make it unique.
Rather than relying on marketing language or generic descriptions, our goal is to create the most complete and trustworthy resource available for each community we cover. Whether you're buying, selling, or simply exploring Sarasota's luxury real estate market, we hope these guides help you make more informed decisions and discover the communities that best fit your lifestyle.